EXECUTIVE SUMMARY. Under the threat of being pulled up for contempt of court by the Supreme Court of India, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) finally disclosed the confidential inspection reports, called Risk Assessment Reports, of some banks requested under the Right to Information Act (RTI), 2005. The reports, though dated (from FY2013 till FY2015), provide a valuable insight into the actual working of banks, at times in contrast to the management’s commentary to shareholders at that time. In the case of Axis Bank, the divergence of views of the management and the banking supervisor is evident. Many in the sell-side and business media tend to regard management’s commentary with reverence, and these supposed sentinels regurgitate the same to their clients and the public without the rigour of critical evaluation. The now public disclosures of the RARs of banks is a rude wake-up call to these watchpersons to thoroughly scrutinize and challenge audited accounts and management commentary. Media reports cite that Axis Bank may be considering a US$ 1.3 bn equity issue, and although a new CEO has taken charge, investors may well want to exercise caution regarding management commentary in light of the RARs that have been made public.
Recent Posts
Most Popular
Remembering Napoleon and Dad
Rabindra Kishen Hazari Jr.
Napoleon was very short. He was my father's hero. Dad, Rabindra Kishen Hazari, was also very short, barely 5'3, and he...
Open War in Karnataka Bank as CEO, ED Defy Board
Tucked away in the notes to the 4QFY2025 accounts of Karnataka Bank, a century-old regional private sector bank which once enjoyed a conservative reputation,...
Yes Bank’s Retail Fiasco: The Rot Is at the Top
In June 2024, Yes Bank sacked at least 500 junior staff, mainly in its retail division (as reported by The Economic Times on June...
Ever-Vigilant CRISIL, India Rating Downgrade Firm – After Default
The raison d’etre of credit rating agencies (CRAs) is to anticipate events such as defaults before they occur. With access to companies’ privileged information,...
Farcical Saga of Axis Bank’s Chief Audit Executives
On February 3, Axis Bank got a new Chief Audit Executive (CAE); on February 12, it changed its CAE once again; in six months,...